Public Health Newswire
States can learn from each other when implementing universal healthcare
- Mary Stortstrom
Federal health officials are unlikely to promote “Medicaid for all” on a nationwide scale, but state legislatures and health departments have the power to make changes that can ease residents’ financial concerns and potentially save states millions of dollars.
Some states, like Connecticut, have implemented successful single-payer healthcare systems. Other states, like Ohio, are taking note.
In 1996, Connecticut began contracting with private, commercial managed care organizations to run the state’s Medicaid program, HUSKY. It turned out to be an abject failure, leading to skyrocketing program costs and an overwhelming workload for Connecticut’s Department of Social Services staff.
Fast forward 30 years and the healthcare landscape in Connecticut looks much different. Residents have greater access to quality healthcare, and Connecticut is one of the leading states in keeping Medicaid costs under control. The reason? The state abandoned the MCO model and switched to a nonprofit, third-party administrator to run HUSKY.
Johnathon S. Ross, with the Toledo Lucas County Board of Health, in Toledo, Ohio, saw the success of Connecticut’s healthcare program and the savings it generated and wondered if something similar could be applied in Ohio.
Physicians for a National Health Program has analyzed the benefits of de-privatizing Medicaid in other states, including Ohio, where the organization estimates the state could save between $490 million and $834 million annually.
“The U.S. is probably wasting about a trillion dollars a year by not adopting a universal, unified healthcare system,” Ross said while presenting “The States Can Lead the Way to Coverage for All: Ohio Follows Connecticut with the Medicaid Savings Act” at APHA 2026.
In 2001, public health activists decided that Lucas County, Ohio, and the city of Toledo had enough funding and resources to provide primary insurance to 50,000 uninsured residents. From there, a committee analyzed costs and found that insurance coverage for primary care, basic labs and imaging could be done for roughly half the cost of the old disproportionate share model.
Now, 25 years later, Ross said the program in Toledo and Lucas County is still going strong. These successful single-payer models can be applied in other states, he said, as long as public health professionals advocate for them.
“In Ohio, we have a model that works. It can be done, but you have to be willing to talk to your county council and state legislators,” he said.
According to Ross, for-profit healthcare is a uniquely American problem. He said Americans pay about twice as much for healthcare as the top 30 high-income countries do but still have a lower life expectancy by comparison.
“(Americans) have the best doctors, the best nurses, the best drugs and the best research, but the worst healthcare system,” he said.
Physicians for a National Health Program has a state-by-state list showing potential savings if states switched to single-payer healthcare plans. You can view details for your state on its website.
Photo by Djavan Rodriguez, courtesy iStockphoto.